Earth Treasures Jewelers

(86 reviews)
Michael's Plaza, 178 State Route 35 South Suite 5 Eatontown, NJ | (732) 542-5444
| www.earth-treasures.com
swipe or click to view more
Earth Treasures Jewelers 5 of 5 1 86

86 total reviews

Follow Reviews

show reviews by reviewer type:

Results 1 - 20 of 86

Wedding: 5/2/2008
Member Since: 7/26/2009 verified review
Great service, honest people    posted 4/12/2013

My husband bought my engagement ring and wedding bands at earth treasures, and this month he went back to upgrade my engagement ring for our five year anniversary. He worked with Jenelle who is so knowledgeable patient and friendly, and gives great advice. Their trade in program gave us 100 percent of what her paid for my first ring for my upgrade this year. We will never go anywhere else. Thank you Jenelle!

Service
Quality
Value

Wedding: 6/9/2012
Member Since: 11/9/2010 verified review
Awesome experience    posted 7/4/2012 (updated 7/6/2012)

As a man there is probably few things more intimidating in life than buying a wedding ring and band for the woman you love. Will she love it? Is it big enough? Can I afford it? What makes a good ring? If you aren't already tense, having to deal with a commission based sales person will put you right over the edge. At Earth Treasures there is no pressure. Just very kind sale reps (I worked with 3), especially Robin Ann, who will show you some incredible rings and then explain what makes them so awesome. They are extremely reasonable when it comes to prices, after exhaustively comparing with their competitors, and have a very good selection. Along with the sales staff, they have several gemologists that will literally sit with you as long as you like to explain everything about your diamond. Even if you aren't going to buy it, they want you to be well informed. After the purchase they are wonderful with sizing and offer a lifetime cleaning and tightening on the bands. Each time we've returned we are welcomed by name and asked how life has been. It is a pleasant experience that leaves you feeling excited and not worried or worn down. For that I highly recommend Earth Treasures for any jewelry purchases.

Vendor Comments

We are so pleased to hear that you had such an amazing experience! Here at Earth Treasures we strive for excellence. We understand the value of education when making such an important decision which is why we put so much effort into training our staf...

Quality
Service
Value

Wedding: 9/25/2011
Member Since: 4/19/2011 verified review
the best jewelers ever    posted 10/12/2011

I couldn't have asked for a better jeweler

Quality
Service
Value

Wedding: 6/20/2015
Member Since: 12/29/2013 verified review
Love my ring!    posted 7/10/2014

My fiancée purchased my engagement ring at Earth Treasures. Not only is the ring amazing, but Sherry was so wonderful to work with! Although I was not involved in the ring process, my fiancee still talks about how wonderful the service was and how they took the time to educate him on diamonds. He definitely knows way more about diamonds than I do. I also had to go in to adjust the size and Sherry was understanding and helpful throughout the process. We look forward to going back to Earth Treasures to purchase our wedding bands in a few months :)

Service
Quality
Value

Wedding: 4/18/2014
Member Since: 4/22/2003
Completely decked out in Earth Treasures sparkle on our big day    posted 4/30/2014 (updated 5/1/2014)

We found my BEAUTIFUL Emerald cut engagement ring, and my Tiffany & Co. Platinum diamond eternity wedding band, as well as my husbands wedding band here at Earth Treasures at their wonderful Estate Sale section. Everything in the store is beautiful! Beyond belief. The staff is always SO kind. Deborah Ann was my sales associate and she was so honest and helpful.
A few days before our wedding we had to have my husbands band resized and they rushed it to have it done for us on time and with no charge! And , while on our honeymoon a tiny stone fell out of my engagement ring and they fixed it free of charge so I wouldn't t have to put a claim in through my insurance.
I can't sing their praises enough! I love this place and will continue to shop here for all our schmancy diamond needs.

Service
Quality
Value

Wedding: 10/6/2013
Member Since: 1/20/2012 verified review
Terrific Experience    posted 10/25/2013

Working with Earth Treasures was a pleasure. Janelle was extremely helpful and I truly trusted her opinion. Everyone there was friendly and their merchandise is beautiful!

Quality
Service
Value

Wedding: 7/29/2014
Member Since: 9/2/2013 verified review
Groom    posted 9/2/2013

Earth Treasures was absolutely amazing throughout the entire ring shopping experience. Great products and exceptional staff. Would definitely recommend to all my friends and family!

Service
Quality
Value

Wedding: 10/10/2008
Member Since: 8/22/2013
What a Feeling!!    posted 8/22/2013

I have been a shopper of Earth Treasures for many years. My husband wanted to surprise me with a gift. Lucinda is my personal shopper because she knows me so well. So, my husband upgraded my diamond engagement ring by my surprise!! We always dicussed it but we never did it. I love my new 2Ct Round Brilliant Diamond! Thank you Earth Treasures you have out done yourself on this gift!!Thank you to Lucinda she is an asset to your company!!


Wedding: 11/8/2013
Member Since: 2/25/2009
My beautiful engagement ring!!    posted 8/1/2013

I went with my boyfriend to pick out my engagement ring. 1. I never thought a ring could be so beautiful, it sparkles so much. 2. The service was amazing, I felt like a princess and was able to take my time. I went in with hopes for a princess cut and when I changed to a round cut, they were happy to show me more. I was very please with my whole experience at Earth Treasures, I will definitely recommend them to others and they will be my jeweler of choice for life.

Service
Quality
Value

Wedding: 10/24/2004
Member Since: 7/5/2004 verified review
The Perfect Upgrade    posted 7/9/2013 (updated 7/9/2013)

My husband and I were on a mission to find the perfect wedding set upgrade around Valentine's Day (Married 9 years, together for 13 years!). We went from jewelry store to jewelry store to no prevail, felt no genuinity or true energy. The second we stepped foot into Earth Treasures, we were greeted with warm words by practically the entire staff. The assistant manager, Sherry, personally helped me with the estate section, which we wanted to see before the rest of the store. My heart drew to this gorgeous 1.62ct oval cut diamond with 2 x 0.41ct trillion cut diamonds on the sides, 14k yellow gold, estate engagement ring. The staff gave their honest, knowledgeable opinions from the beginning with choices to the end at checkout. That was when I knew it was THEE perfect upgrade. She was kind enough to steam my engagement ring, help with GE, and had the free appraisal done within 1 business day. The whole process went smoothly with 30 minutes to closing!

The next week, I went to choose a matching wedding band. Sherry again gave me her super honest opinion between all choices. I ended up with an edgeless pave curved wedding band, which I completely fell in love with. They estimated 6-8 weeks for special order and I received it well in advance at 4 weeks (even though I had custom sizing at 4 3/4 and 14k yellow gold). It perfectly framed my engagement ring, without any gaps, and it accented my upgrade like a princess's tiara.

Unfortunately, I wore it to advanced hot yoga the same day and 2 diamonds fell out. I immediately went to Sherry after and she helped me with the jewelers. The jewelers repaired it within 2 days and my wedding set was perfect once again. I cannot thank her enough for her astounding service.

I must have been in Earth Treasures at least 7-8 times in a 6 week span. So much shared and vice versa, Sherry expressed she felt like I'm family. Haha! Every time I went in there, my estate engagement ring was properly cleaned and steamed. And at least 2 staff members always commented on how impressively beautiful my set is. They truly know how to make a woman feel loved! Best personable customer service by far, going above and beyond. I highly recommend them over all others. Definitely a destination jeweler indeed.

Now I walk around proudly with my breathtaking upgrade! It literally stops people in their tracks, asking to see and complimenting on how gorgeous it is. To find such a treasure in their estate collection and the events leading up to it... it was truly fate.

Service
Quality
Value

Wedding: 5/3/2013
Member Since: 5/10/2013 verified review
Deborah Ann Wheaton    posted 5/10/2013

Deborah Ann assisted me last October in finding the perfect engagement ring for my fiancee. She paid close attention to what I was looking for, and made sure to help me find the unique piece that looks so beautiful on my fiancee's finger. Thank you so much Deborah Ann!

Service
Quality
Value

Wedding: 6/1/2012
Member Since: 6/24/2010
Earth Treasures is AMAZING!!    posted 5/7/2013

My husband and I (newlyweds!) are so happy that we chose Earth Treasures as our jeweler! My husband found my beautiful engagement ring there and we also purchased our gorgeous wedding bands there as well. Deborah Ann helped us and she was the absolute best we ever could have asked for! She knew exactly what we wanted and provided us with top-notch service, we couldnt have asked for more! I recommend anyone and everyone goes to Earth Treasures! We will continue to do business with them for years to come :)

The Angerami's

Service
Quality
Value

Wedding: 9/14/2013
Member Since: 3/12/2013 verified review
Awesome Customer Service and Jewelry    posted 4/2/2013

My fiance and I went and looked at styles of rings back in December. Since then she was in the store 7 other times trying to find the perfect ring. The staff was wonderful; never rushed her and invited her to come back multiple times to make sure it was the right one before purchasing. We since then have purchased our wedding bands from there as well! Great Service!

Service
Quality
Value

Member Since: 2/21/2013 verified review
My little peice of treasure    posted 2/21/2013

Just wanted to write a quick thank you to my sales lady joy! She just recently helped me repair my engament ring and it came out stunning. I will be celebrating my 12yr anniversay in April and look forward to working with Joy again. See you soon!

DEE

Service
Quality
Value

Wedding: 6/7/2014
Member Since: 6/14/2012
Class and Comfort at its finest    posted 12/18/2012

This place is great. Everyone is extremely friendly and helpful every time I've been there. However, I really want to thank Robin Ann for all her wonderful service and patience with me. Robin Ann really made me feel comfortable from the moment I sat down. I went from an uneducated engagement ring shopper to a satisfied customer. Most importantly, my fiancé is happy and loved the ring!

Thank you for all your help and we will be, and have been, back for any future jewelry needs.

Quality
Service
Value

Wedding: 10/14/2012
Member Since: 11/14/2012 verified review
Beth Is The Best!!!!    posted 11/14/2012

My family has been shopping at ET for many years. They are our jeweler of choice. However, as a couple, we just cannot say enough good things about Beth! Our shopping experience started at Earth Treasures February 2011 when my fiance at the time bought me the most beautiful martini set diamond earrings for Valentines Day. We had looked there many times, dealt w many wonderful sales people but had never made a purchase. The fit seemed right w Beth bc my fiance couldn't stop raving about her when he presented me w the earrings. By sheer luck, not really knowing anyone's name there, he got Beth! Now we know to put her name down on the list & ask specifically for her!!! (and we suggest you do the same)but the truth is that everyone at Earth Treasures is really knowledgeable & wonderful. When it came time to purchase an engagement ring there was no doubt in our minds that ET would be the store. We actually didn't meet w Beth that day &were so upset by it that we just continued to go back over & over w any questions we had or cleanings that we wanted done & specifically asked for her. She assured us that the women who helped us that day were fabulous, that Helene really knew so much about diamonds, that we were in good hands & had made a great selection. But Beth really went above & beyond from that point forward. She sat w us, plotted our diamond out for us. We learned everything there was to know about our investment. She checked my ring when I thought the stone might be loose & had it tightened up immediately. She was always so accommodating, so caring. We knew we would absolutely buy our bands there & our a special piece for the mother of the bride to wear & Beth was with us every step of the way from that moment on. She took so much time w us when it came to choosing our bands & made sure we both loved what we were picking. We felt so comfortable w her, so confident about our purchase. She was amazing! She & Lucinda helped us every time we went in. They would wave to us from across the store, it was such a wonderful feeling to know they remembered us & wanted to help us! These ladies went over every single thing w us every time we went. It is an overwhelming experience..just getting engaged, choosing the exact right diamond, then the bands, the entire wedding experience is a lot to take in. We really consider Beth a friend at this point. She made every part of the experience fun! She never discouraged us, never let us down. We always left w a sense of pride & accomplishment. Bc my ring was a custom design she made sure my band would be a great fit for the ring & would look really beautiful together and they do, and I love my rings!!!!! Right down to a couple days bf when we picked up our polished & gorgeous rings, Beth was there holding our hands, walking us through everything. She & Jesse helped to pick the perfect gift to present to my mom that morning in the bridal suite. They also engraved our bands for us, making them truly one of a kind now. We really feel so honored to have met Beth & know we couldn't have done any of it without her. She is so special to us that my husband insisted that she come to our wedding! I was so happy & surprised to see my now good friend Beth & Lucinda at our ceremony. I had no idea they would be there to see me take my vows but they were:) Beth Watson was one of the main reasons that my wedding was such a beautiful, unforgettable day!

Quality
Service
Value

Wedding: 5/20/2012
Member Since: 11/14/2012
BETH IS THE BEST - SERIOUSLY!    posted 11/14/2012 (updated 11/14/2012)

I'm not a big yapper - I will tell you simply I went to a few jewelry stores before trying Earth Treasures & now I will never go anywhere else....as long as Beth is there.
I came in off the street - described what I wanted & she was able to translate that into a ring more beautiful than I could have imagined.
Since then I have also had earrings & a necklace made there - all 100% amazing.
Not often you find someone so knowledgable - creative & professional.
Whatever your budget - I would try here first.

Quality
Service
Value

Wedding: 8/6/2011
Member Since: 8/1/2010 verified review
Earth Treasures is Awesome!    posted 11/8/2012

My now nusband really enjoyed the selection process for my engagement ring. Robin Ann really made it less stressful in her understanding way. We would highly recommend her! We were so happy with our engagement ring and the clean up services following the purchase that we also purchased our wedding bands there as well. I still go back once a year to get my ring cleaned and the diamonds checked out for security reasons. Earth Treasures hasn't forgotten about me. They continue to give diligent service :)

Quality
Service
Value

Wedding: 2/2/2013
Member Since: 10/19/2012 verified review
Outstanding Service and work    posted 11/5/2012

I was born and raised in NJ and moved to GA 14 years go. I have always had a great experience with Earth Treasures in the past but my last surpasses them all.

I was staying in NJ this past summer to help with my parents. While I was there we had found my paternal grandmother's engagement ring.

With the blessing of my fiancé we had agreed to see if we could get his diamond placed in the setting.

I went in and met with Joy D'Aniello, who immediately took me under her wing and assured me that it could be done. She took the rings to the jeweler for review and came back and told me that it would be possible to do this and it would be done in 10 business days.

I shared with Joy that my fiancé was coming in 1 week to pick me up to take me back to GA and if there was any possible way that is could be done by then. She said, "Sure" without a blink of an eye, and put a rush on the order. It was obvious to me that Joy had completely understood my situation and was there to help me in any way she could. They took a diagram of the diamond, had a copy for them and one for me. This was for me to compare upon my return to confirm that it was my diamond.

In the meanwhile my father had shared with me that the setting had actually been designed and created by my great-great grandfather who was a jeweler in Stugart, Germany. This then made the ring even more special to me because it wraps up all my family in one precious gift.

I returned the following week to pick up my ring. It was absolutely the most beautiful thing I have ever saw that it gave me chill bumps and brought tears to my eyes. Joy was there with me to enjoy the moment and by now have connected with her in more than a "customer" but as a friend.

I went home to share with my parents and my mom cried. My fiancé was astonished and I can honestly say that my ring is one of a kind.

Joy is an asset to Earth Treasures and I would recommend her to anyone that would like to meet someone that is not only great at her job but genuinely cares. All the employees there are great but Joy has become now a friend.
I am now in GA planning my wedding that will be in February and having to find wedding bands. Wishing that there was a “Joy” and “Earth Treasures” here to help me. Once you have an OUTSTANDING experience like that it is hard find someone else that can be compared.

Quality
Service
Value

Member Since: 10/28/2012
Earth Treasures is a true gem    posted 10/28/2012

I have been a customer of Earth Treasures for many years. Their jewelry and staff is unsurpassed. Marion has been my sales professional for more than 20 years, her expertise and attention to detail cannot be matched. In an age where we tend to lose that personal touch, it is wonderful to know there is a store that prides itself in putting the customer first and valuing customer loyalty.

Results 1 - 20 of 86


Life's Treasured Moments Begin at Earth Treasures

Earth Treasures, fine jewelry since 1974. Winner of the Reader's Choice award for best jeweler in Monmouth County for 15 consecutive years. Specializing in diamonds, gems, pearl's, bridal gifts and custom design jewelry. One's imagination is the only limit to creating your dream of a lifetime.


awards and affiliations

  • The Knot Best of Weddings 2014The Knot Best Of Weddings 2014
  • The Knot Best of Weddings 2013The Knot Best Of Weddings 2013