Patty Cakes

(17 reviews)
1018 Laurel St Highland, IL map | (618) 654-8180
| http://www.pat-t-cakes.com/
Patty Cakes 4 of 5 1 17

17 total reviews

Follow Reviews

show reviews by reviewer type:

Results 1 - 17 of 17
  • 1

Wedding: 9/21/2013
Member Since: 6/20/2012 verified review
Loved the end result    posted 10/18/2013

I went into the cake shop with a vision and wondered whether or not I was able to get across to them exactly what I wanted. I was amazed when I saw the wedding cake! I was so happy with the end result!


Wedding: 6/29/2013
Member Since: 9/30/2012 verified review
tasty    posted 7/26/2013

Our wedding cake was beautiful and delicious! Everyone loved it.

Quality
Service
Value

Wedding: 6/16/2012
Member Since: 8/29/2010 verified review
Wedding cake    posted 7/23/2012

Patty cakes did an amazing job. They paid attention to every detail that I wanted on my cake. The final product was gorgeous and not to mention, they have the best tasting cake in the st. louis area. She was also the winner of TLC's cake off. She also did our groomsman cake and everyone at the restaurant was taking pictures because it was really awesome.

Quality
Service
Value

Wedding: 6/2/2012
Member Since: 3/2/2011 verified review
Delicious!!    posted 6/18/2012

All of my guests loved our cake! Other than the top of our cake there was none left and we had 20 rsvp that they would show up and didn't! We had red velvet with cream cheese filling and french vanilla with strawberry cream cheese filling.

Quality
Service
Value

Wedding: 11/19/2011
Member Since: 10/11/2010 verified review
Fantastic cake, worth every penny.    posted 12/20/2011

I thought the cake price was a little high, but after the tasting I could see why. My biggest concern was that the final product wouldn't taste like all of the samples we went through, but I was wrong. They have so many interesting cakes and fillings to try, and they are very friendly. They worked with us on getting the design we wanted and every detail to be exact, and it was. It's a little far, pick-up wasn't a bit problem but free delivery would be awesome.

Quality
Service
Value

Wedding: 11/11/2011
Member Since: 10/5/2009 verified review
So yummy    posted 11/26/2011

I wanted a Patty Cake cake before I was engaged, so to be able to have one for my wedding was wonderful, the team were friendly and attentive, we got exactly what we asked for, it was so good, there was none left!

Quality
Service
Value

Wedding: 10/15/2011
Member Since: 8/15/2010 verified review
Beautiful Cake    posted 11/12/2011

We had a consultation with Patty Cakes during which they helped us design our cake, and let us try all the flavors of cake and filling that they offer. We wanted to incorporate a stained glass design in our cake and they were more than willing to brainstorm ideas on how to do that. They helped us design a beautiful wedding cake and we got nothing but rave reviews about the taste of the cake. The staff is very professional and knows what they are doing. They are also reasonably priced considering the quality of their cakes. I highly recommend Patty Cakes!

Quality
Service
Value

Wedding: 9/17/2011
Member Since: 3/10/2011 verified review
all talk    posted 10/31/2011

lets just say they are all talk and OVeR priced our cake leaned about 4 in!!! The filling was all obsorbed into the cake the fondont was tore and bubbled they were rude and didn't do anything or refund any money for there mistakes!


Wedding: 9/17/2011
Member Since: 11/28/2010 verified review
AWFUL!    posted 10/4/2011

Would not recommend. They were not friendly, and made changes to my cake 4 days before the wedding that I was not happy with. I paid a lot of money for a cake that didn't even feed all of my guests (which is not what we had agreed on!) They didn't even ATTEMPT to match the color swatch that I drove 1.5 hours to take to them. They just used a generic color, which was not similar to what I brought to them. Yes, the cake is delicious, but you will pay for it, way over priced, and they are not friendly and willing to help make this cake be the most special cake you have ever had! Very disappointed with the service, would NOT recommend!

Quality
Service
Value

Wedding: 8/12/2011
Member Since: 10/28/2010 verified review
The best cake I've ever eaten!    posted 8/29/2011

I have been to plenty of weddings and normally the cake is all right. The cakes at Patty Cakes are absolutely amazing! I had a 4 tiered cake, vanilla with strawberry cream cheese filling, chocolate with peanut butter filling, butter pecan with carmel filling and red velvet. Each layer was better than the next! I had more people compliment our cake than anything else at the wedding. We had left over cake and ate it several days later and it was just as moist as at the wedding. Not only was the cake good, it was also beautiful! Patty Cakes took my design and made it so much prettier than I would have ever imagined, and Patty was wonderful to work with!

Quality
Service
Value

Wedding: 7/2/2011
Member Since: 8/8/2010 verified review
Yummy!    posted 7/28/2011

My cake looked beautiful and tasted delicious too! My favorite layer was the french vanilla cake with strawberry and cream cheese filling!! MMMM!!

Quality
Service
Value

Wedding: 6/19/2010
Member Since: 12/21/2008 verified review
Patty Cakes    posted 2/2/2011

Fantastic! We used my great grandmother's cake topper from her wedding, and they did a great job tying in the old with the new! Our cake looked very modern.

Quality
Service
Value

Wedding: 11/27/2010
Member Since: 8/30/2009 verified review
Cake    posted 1/1/2011

I did not use them, but my cousin did for her wedding, and they provided a great service and great cake! The only thing is her cake toppled at the reception right away so no one got to see it very long if at all.

Quality
Service
Value

Wedding: 11/13/2010
Member Since: 8/9/2009 verified review
Very Pretty    posted 12/14/2010

Every thing looked beautiful and I heard it tasted great (forgot to try any other than that first bite)They are just very regimented...I was scared that if I did something wrong, they would take my cake away.

Quality
Service
Value

Wedding: 9/11/2010
Member Since: 1/28/2008 verified review
Beautiful and Tasty Cake    posted 9/28/2010

Patty Cakes makes the most beautiful and best tasting cakes. My wedding cake was even better than I could have ever imagined. Everyone loved it and we hardly had any left. The few leftovers we had were gone the next day as everyone wanted more.

Quality
Service
Value

Wedding: 6/26/2010
Member Since: 5/31/2009 verified review
Beautiful Cakes.....OK taste    posted 8/10/2010

I was really excited to have Patty Cakes as my cake vendor because she has appeared on food networks cake challenge twice and won both times. Our wedding cake was absolutely beautiful. The small detail on it was amazing and the flowers brought by my florist were places beautifully on by Patty.

Although the cake looked awesome, we did encounter one problem with this vendor. When we placed out order, we told them that we needed cake for 250 people. There were 220 people at my wedding and we ran out of cake! I didn't even get a piece of my own wedding cake (besides the small piece that my husband and I fed each other). Also, when my mom checked in with the caterer who was cutting it, the caterer said it was very crumbly and was having trouble with the pieces staying together.

After the wedding, my mom called Patty Cakes and told them about the situation. They did make another cake that would feed about 30 people (just white cake with white icing). But when we ate it, I thought that it was very crumbly too and the icing was a sugary icing and not creamy. It did not taste like the cake that we had sampled when we were checking them out before the wedding.

I'm not sure if this was just a fluke, but I was not really happy for what we paid...about $600. On the positive, the cake was gorgeous. But I think people always remember how it tasted, not how it looked!

Quality
Service
Value

Wedding: 5/1/2010
Member Since: 12/27/2008
Terrible customer service & cake was wrong    posted 5/17/2010

First the experience started by meeting with the snotty Pat "the owners assistant" Out of m and the 3 relatives that went with me all that she had a way about her of saying things.
The cake was delicious but not nearly as good upon delivery. On top of it our bottom layer was not the flavor or filling as requested and once my mother brought it up to them (while we were on our honeymoon) they made her basically sound like she was stupid and told her "we never make mistakes". Very hard to believe unless the person who said that stacked the cakes herself which she did not. Im thinking that now that the owner is on TLC she hasnt a clue as to how the customer service is while she is gone. Then again, she was just as snippy in her email to me when I let her know my concern. Our order ws in for over a year, couldnt get it right and after the amount of money spent they couldnt at least be decent about it, instead they were hateful. I should have known from the first meeting to go somewhere else where people are pleasant and appreciate your business still!

Quality
Service
Value
Results 1 - 17 of 17
  • 1

At Patty Cakes, we want your wedding to be unforgettable, so let us design an original work of art for you. Every wedding cake is custom-designed to fit your occasion, whether it is wild and whimsical, glitzy and glamorous, or simple and elegant. Sample the rest then hire the best.


  • Type: Cake Tops & Accessories

awards and affiliations

  • The Knot Best of Weddings 2013The Knot Best Of Weddings 2013