Edith Meyer Wedding Cakes

(10 reviews)
By Appointment Only Santa Cruz, CA | (831) 212-1447
| www.edithmeyer.com
Edith Meyer Wedding Cakes 5 of 5 1 10

10 total reviews

Follow Reviews

show reviews by reviewer type:

Results 1 - 10 of 10
  • 1

Wedding: 5/18/2013
Member Since: 1/16/2003 verified review
The most beautiful and delicious wedding cake ever...and it was gluten-free!!!    posted 5/26/2013

My husband and I got married on May 18, 2013, and Edith did our wedding cake. Both John and I are gluten-free and we were worried we wouldn't be able to find a good gluten-free wedding cake option. Boy, was that worry unfounded. Edith gave us several samples and we tried the chocolate first and both had to confirm that we were eating a gluten-free cake because it was so firm, moist and delicious. It was better than most regular cakes I have had.

We are so happy we found her and our cake was beautiful and delicious and Edith was so sweet and easy to work with. Our guests loved it so much that several went back for seconds and thirds. Luckily our coordinator put a few slices aside for us so we could have more than just the bites we had at the cutting! It was so yummy and by far the best gluten-free option in the area!!

Service
Quality
Value

Wedding: 8/3/2012
Member Since: 8/30/2011 verified review
I am still dreaming about cake!    posted 9/20/2012

When planning my wedding the cake was one of my "most important items" and I knew what I wanted. I wanted a main cake that was non-traditional. I also needed a side cake that was gluten-free. And at least one of these cakes needed to be vegan. Additionally, the cake had to be moist and taste amazing and be made of natural ingredients. I have heard too many complaints from friends who loved how cakes at weddings looked but did not love eating them.

Edith's cakes are delicious! Our main wedding cake was shaped like a sand castle (which matched our oceanside venue) and was a cream cake with vanilla bean buttercream. The side cake was a vegan and gluten-free chocolate cake with a strawberry filling and a vanilla bean vegan buttercream frosting. Edith can tell you where she sources her products, including her own garden!

When the cakes were sliced, everyone wanted to try both! Luckily our caterers sliced the cakes thin enough to match these requests (although we ended up with tons of left over cake - but everyone got to try both and still be satisfied!). Everyone who tried both cakes said they couldn't tell the second one was vegan and GF! That says a LOT about the quality! And our guests with dairy and gluten allergies could actually enjoy cake at a wedding. As I mentioned, we had a lot of leftover cake. So unlike other cake companies, Edith bakes with real servings in mind.

My only regret was that we didn't have enough to-go boxes and most of the leftovers never made it home!!!

Can I plan another event just so I can have some cake?

Quality
Service
Value

Wedding: 6/30/2012
Member Since: 4/6/2011 verified review
msMP    posted 7/30/2012

Our cake didn't turn out exactly as we wanted, but looked gorgeous. We never received a watercolor sketch of our cake design, as others stated they had and even mentions on the website. We asked for our cake to be red velvet with just the top being carrot cake, but ended up getting 1 layer of red velvet and 2 of carrot. Slight miscommunication. But Edith was very accomodating with our design changes, to meet our budget and guest count changes.

Quality
Service
Value

Wedding: 9/10/2011
Member Since: 9/26/2007 verified review
So Yummy    posted 11/1/2011

Whipped cream cake with hazelnut buttercream
Red velvet cake with chocolate buttercream
Both with vanilla bean butter cream

Sound delicious right? It was. EXTREMELY.

If the wedding cake is a priority for you this is a sure bet. Beautiful and yummy.

Quality
Service
Value

Wedding: 9/18/2011
Member Since: 8/29/2010 verified review
Amazing wedding cake!    posted 10/9/2011

My husband and I had the idea of making our wedding cake look like an old world (open) photo album with pictures of us. The cake looked so real and we had so many guests attempt to turn the page that we had to put up a sign that said it was cake! It was a big hit and all the guests loved it!

Quality
Service
Value

Wedding: 9/17/2011
Member Since: 2/15/2010 verified review
Yummy    posted 9/30/2011

Edith was the first cake baker that didn't laugh in my face when I told her that I wanted a naked cake. Meaning now foundit/butter cream frosting on the outside of my cake. In fact she had already done one and that pretty much sealed the deal. Oh she also was the first cake baker that understood that my husband can't have any dairy products and she was willing to bake a special non-dairy cupcake for him for our big day. The cake was amazing and exactly what we wanted. We cared more about how the cake tasted then it being some big over the top looking cake. We choose an organic lemon pound cake with oholaa berry cream filling and it was amazing. Coming from a bride that ate only ate a bagel on her wedding day the cake was the best tasting thing I have ever had.

Edith does an amazing job and from the time you meet and do your tasting to the time she delivers your cake she there for you and you will dream about your cake.

Quality
Service
Value

Wedding: 7/3/2011
Member Since: 9/6/2010 verified review
Beautiful and Scrumptious Wedding Cake!    posted 7/20/2011

Edith created a gorgeous four layer cake with fresh flower decoration for our wedding. We chose four different cake flavors: chocolate/hazelnut, coconut with fresh raspberries and lemon filling (my personal favorite!), carrot cake, and chocolate with decadent chocolate ganache. We had so many comments from our guests that the cakes were the best they had ever tasted at a wedding! The carrot cake and coconut cake were both especially flavorful and delicious.

I'm trying to figure out another reason to order a cake from Edith for another celebratory event :)

Quality
Service
Value

Wedding: 9/10/2006
Member Since: 3/13/2006
Review for Edith Meyer Wedding Cakes    posted 5/10/2010

Made exactly what we wanted from fresh, organic ingredients - no restrictions.


Wedding: 8/25/2007
Member Since: 4/7/2006
Review for Edith Meyer Wedding Cakes    posted 8/31/2007

We ordered about 1.5 times the number of cupcakes as we had guests - we only had 4 left. They were amazing. And Edith's ability to incorporate our wedding design onto our cakes was impeccable.


Wedding: 6/23/2007
Member Since: 8/14/2006
Review for Edith Meyer Wedding Cakes    posted 8/31/2007

I had a very particular idea in mind for my dream cake - I wanted the cake to be hand painted to mirror a floral painting done by my late great-grandmother. After a lot of searching, we found Edith Meyer. We loved that she uses mainly organic ingredients for her cake. And she was game for the challenge. The cake was incredibly beautiful and it seemed as if my great-grandmother had hand painted it herself. Very special. Edith was great to work with, artistic and bakes a delicious cake. I loved that she delivered and set up the cakes herself - great attention to detail. The cake flavors were so good we ended up having three smaller cakes.;The Santa Cruz location was a little bit of a stretch from the Bay Area, but entirely worth it!

Results 1 - 10 of 10
  • 1

Simple elegance with local, organic ingredients.

We work with local, organic farmers to source everything from eggs to the most flavorful seasonal fruits and vegetables. The delicious results are incomparable, and our designs are inspired by personal elements from your wedding to create a truly special ending for your perfect day.


  • Price Range: $$$

awards and affiliations

  • The Knot Best of Weddings 2012The Knot Best Of Weddings 2012